Finding Your Place Without Losing Yourself in a New Family

Dear Curious Christie and Ms. Resilient,

“I recently became a stepparent, and no matter what I do, I can’t seem to shake the feeling of being an outsider in my new family. The kids are polite enough—quick hellos, quick goodnights—but conversations stay surface-level, and real connection feels just out of reach.

I try to show up for them—attending soccer games, helping with homework when asked, giving them space when they seem to need it—but I constantly find myself second-guessing every move. Am I being too pushy? Too distant? Too eager? There are moments when I feel like I’m standing in the doorway of their world, unsure if I’m welcome or just tolerated.

I want to build real, lasting relationships with them, but I’m scared of forcing something that isn’t ready—or worse, losing parts of myself by trying too hard to fit into a role I’m still figuring out.

How do I create a genuine connection without pushing too hard—or disappearing altogether?”

~Standing in the Doorway

Dear Standing in the Doorway, 

First, let’s just take a breath together because what you’re navigating is big. Blending into a new family—especially as a stepparent—is like being dropped into the middle of a story that’s partly written. You're learning the characters, the plot twists, the unspoken rules... all while trying to write your own chapter with love and care. It’s no wonder you feel like you’re standing in the doorway, unsure if you’re supposed to knock, walk in, or wait to be invited.

Let’s start with the first truth: your feelings matter. It’s painful to offer your heart and feel like you're met with polite distance instead of open arms. It’s natural to second-guess yourself when every effort feels a little wobbly. You are not silly, selfish, or weak for wanting to belong.

But here’s the second truth—and it’s an important one: those kids’ feelings matter more.Their world has shifted in ways they didn’t choose. Even if they like you, even if they someday love you, trust and connection take time, and kids can be slower to open doors when their world has just been shifted. It’s not a rejection of you —it’s a reflection of where they are on their own emotional path.

Real connection can’t be rushed. It grows in small, quiet ways:

• The steady showing up at soccer games.

• The simple “good morning,” even when it's barely mumbled back.

• The patient offers of help without strings attached.

Every one of those small moments is like a line in a larger story—even if you can’t see the full plot yet, you’re helping to write something meaningful.

The trick (and the grace) is staying yourself while also letting the kids set the pace. You don’t have to perform or disappear. You just have to be present, authentic, and patient. You are adding your own chapter to the story of this family, even if you don’t know exactly how it all comes together yet.

With heart and hope,

Curious Christie 

Dear Standing in the Doorway,

Christie’s thoughtful reply reminds me of one of Dovetail Learning’s most steadying Connecting Skills: Empathizing.

Empathizing isn’t just about understanding someone’s feelings—it’s about holding space for those feelings without needing to fix them or rush their process. That’s exactly what you’re doing, even if it doesn’t always feel like it. You're noticing their cues, respecting their pace, and asking thoughtful questions of yourself, all in an effort to meet them where they are—not where you wish they were.

What makes your reflection especially poignant is that you’re practicing Empathizing both outwardly and inwardly. You’re trying to feel into their world—the awkward hellos, the surface-level chats, the hesitation that might be protecting something tender. You are giving them the space to be where they are, even if it doesn’t feel great for you. At the same time, you’re learning to empathize with your own uncertainty, grief, and desire to belong. That’s brave. That’s resilient. 

Empathy often grows best in spaces where expectations soften and curiosity takes the lead. You don’t have to be perfect or even always confident—you just have to remain open. And vulnerable. By honoring the kids’ pace while staying true to yourself, you’re creating the kind of bridge that real connection can walk across.

You’re not standing in the doorway alone—you’re waiting with your heart open. That matters more than you know.

With admiration,

Ms. Resilient

What advice do you have for Standing in the Doorway? Share in the comments or send to ms@dovetaillearning.org and we may feature your answer in a future column.

Curious Christie and Ms. Resilient love to hear from you!

We love sharing resilience wisdom! For advice, please click on the button or email us at ms@dovetaillearning.org.